How College Rankings Can Hurt You

Yesterday, in writing about the latest college rankings scandal on my college blog, I mentioned that the institutional pursuit of college rankings glory, has hurt millions of students in ways they can’t even imagine. Today I want to elaborate on that observation.

If you missed yesterday’s post, here it is:

Colleges and Universities That Cheat

Millions of students are adversely impacted by the rankings competition because of the actions of the audience that cares most deeply about the numbers – college presidents and their boards of trustees, and by extension, their admission offices. For these folks, US News has provided them with an easy (though deeply flawed) scorecard to measure how their institutions are faring and they are distraught if their school’s ranking stalls out, or worse, drops.

What the Rankings Don’t Measure!

Perhaps aggressive pursuit of higher rankings wouldn’t be a bad thing if the rankings actually measured what sort of job a college or university was doing to educate its undergrads. One of the perverse aspects about the rankings is that turning out thoughtful, articulate young men and women, who can write cogently and think critically won’t budge a school’s ranking up even one spot. Curiously enough, U.S. News doesn’t even attempt to measure the type of learning going on at schools.

Unfortunately, the methodology fueling the rankings are a collection of subjective measurements that students and families are supposed to rely upon to pinpoint the schools doing the best job of educating undergraduates. U.S. News relies on proxies for educational quality, but these proxies are dubious at best.

 Colleges Behaving Badly

Here are just three of the ways that the rankings hurt students and their parents:

1. Rankings encourage colleges to favor affluent students.

Many teenagers end up as collateral damage in the rankings race because schools that are more selective are rated higher, which encourages them to accept more wealthy students. US News awards schools which generate higher test scores and grade point averages from their freshmen. This focus on selectivity has been a boon for affluent high school students, who tend to enjoy better academic profiles. These teens can afford expensive test-prep courses and are more likely to have attended schools with stronger academic offerings. There is a strong positive correlation between standardized test scores and family income.

Before the rankings became so prominent, rich students typically had to pay full price for college. The majority of grants were reserved for middle-class and low-income students, who required financial help. But with the rankings premium linked to top students, private and public institutions began offering merit scholarships to entice smart, wealthy students to their campuses rather than to their competitors. How do you cough up the money for these deal sweeteners? One way is to raise the tuition price to generate extra revenue for these scholarships and another way is to reduce the financial aid to needy students.

The only schools that don’t offer merit scholarships to rich students are the institutions that don’t have to. Wealthy parents whose children get into Harvard or Swarthmore will be happy to write checks worth a quarter of a million dollars or more. The most elite schools boast that they reserve their aid to the families who need financial help to attend college, but most of these institutions offer admissions to a shamefully low percentage of needy students.

2. Rankings encourage admission tricks

US News’ algorithm also favors schools that spurn more students. To increase their rejection rates, some schools will court students through marketing materials and social media that they have no intention of accepting. Here’s another trick: some institutions have made it easy for students to apply via streamlined online applications, which are referred to in the industry as “fast apps.” Schools use this strategy to increase the size of their student body, as well as bump up their rejection rates.

3. Rankings encourage debt.

Sadly, what the rankings giant ignores is how much debt students are incurring at their schools. It’s a terrible omission that is certainly one reason why college tuition continues to defy inflation. US News rewards schools that spend freely and the rankings juggernaut doesn’t care if that requires universities to boost their prices and graduate students with staggering debt.

I wrote a longer post about this phenomenon last year for my CBS MoneyWatch college blog. Here is the link:

Blaming College Rankings for Runaway College Costs

Malcolm Gladwell wrote a fascinating article for The New Yorker last year on college rankings in which he talked about the incentive of institutions to turn their campuses into lavish palaces and stick the bill with the kids:

Finally, I’d urge you to read an article in the Washington Monthly that focuses on George Washington University, one of the countless schools that’s been guilty of this bad behavior. Here is the link:

The Prestige Racket

Read more on The College Solution:

Yawn, Harvard is No. 1 University, But Who Is Always No. 3?

Why US News’ College Rankings Are a Joke

Lynn O’Shaughnessy is the author of The College Solution and She also writes a college blog for  CBSMoneyWatch and US News. Follow her on Twitter.

Join Me at My College Workshop on Saturday!

There are a few slots left for the college workshop that I will be  holding at the University of California, San Diego this Saturday (Feb. 4). At the Finding the Right College Workshop, you will learn specific strategies to increase your child’s admission chances, ways to evaluate colleges and universities, essential ACT and SAT information and, yes,  what you need to know about  college rankings!

You can learn more here and sign up for the workshop here.

 

 

, , , ,

10 Responses to How College Rankings Can Hurt You

  1. Rich February 6, 2012 at 10:55 pm #

    Hi Lynn. I agree with you that the rankings game has really encouraged some bad behavior amongst many institutions. To your point about the rankings missing what should be the colleges’ main institutional goal – “how well it educates it’s undergrads”, I was wondering what your opinion is of the separate rankings that US News published on “Colleges That Have the Best Undergraduate Teaching”? That would seem to get closer to what you are looking for. Dartmouth, which has a strong reputation for focus on undergrads tops the list, while Beloit, among others, makes the top 15 for LAC’s. Do you think this type of ranking, although still done via survey results, provides a better insight as to which colleges might be more focused on the right things – specifically providing focus on undergrad learning.

    • Lynn O'Shaughnessy February 7, 2012 at 3:02 am #

      Hi Rich,

      I wouldn’t put much stock in US News’s best undergraduate teaching. I hadn’t known about it, but when I read the short explanation it said these were schools mentioned in a survey of college administrators. One of the big problems that I have with the rankings is that it is heavily dependent on what people not connected to the school think and really how would they know. Also, teaching quality can vary by department and by teachers within departments. I thought it was interesting that one of the schools that was on the best teaching lists — Truman State — was on the list of the worst teaching based on RateMyProfessor.com rankings that Forbes compiles for its rankings.

      Lynn O’Shaughnessy

  2. Krishna April 10, 2012 at 5:23 pm #

    Hi Lynn, by the way you mentionned the Forbes, I think that the fact Forbes compiles in his ranking the debt after graduation is a good thing, is it not? We are from a low income family, debt of education is a huge issue.

    My son intents to go to engineering major in material science (or biotech). He is suggested by colleges board the Worcester University. We studied the school and realized that Worcestor has a long history of reputation. However, Worcester is badly ranked by Forbes.

    Can you give us some explaination and advices.

    Best

    • Lynn O'Shaughnessy April 10, 2012 at 6:06 pm #

      Hi Krishna,

      I think you are referring to Worcester Polytechnic Institute (WPI) it has very poor financial aid. Low-income students should typically stay away from this school.

      Lynn O’Shaughnessy

      • Krishna April 10, 2012 at 9:50 pm #

        Thank you Lynn

        Besides the WPI, what do you think about Tufts, Rice, Harvey Mudd, Boston University, Northeastern University (they are also recommended by Colleges Board) ?

        he wants to try the hard ones like MIT, Caltech, but I think it is too much (his SAT 1830, he will try an other test)

        We prepare also a back up plan with small college like Occidental which has a combine program to engineering.

        Thank you for every advices

        Krishna

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Why College/University Rankings Should Be Handled with Care | Global University Choices - March 15, 2012

    [...] Lynn O’Shaugnessy, who writes for CBS Money Watch as well as her own College Solution blog, attacks the same topic but focuses on the US News & World Report college rankings, the best known but highly controversial rankings of US colleges and universities:  How College Rankings Can Hurt You. [...]

  2. An Email from a Disillusioned Mom | The College Solution - March 22, 2012

    [...] How College Rankings Can Hurt You [...]

  3. Email from a Happy Mom | The College Solution - March 23, 2012

    [...] It’s been frustrating to watch our daughter’s friends make their choices based on the US News rankings, as I fear they will be very disappointed.  But for us, your advice has been proven very sound, [...]

  4. Which College Should This Teenager Attend? | The College Solution - April 9, 2012

    [...] How College Rankings Can Hurt You [...]

  5. Sharing a College's Return on Investment | The College Solution - June 19, 2012

    [...] hard data on learning and job outcomes, families tend to turn to college rankings, which are not proxies for academic quality. Rankings simply serve as a measure of a school’s [...]

Leave a Reply

Powered by WishList Member - Membership Software